Imagine that you are a defense attorney arguing against civil commitment for your client. Based on text material, describe three different reasons you could give the judge for not committing your client.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer is First, I would argue that my client does not meet the criteria for civil commitment. In order to be committed, a person must be found to be a danger to themselves or others due to a mental illness. I would present evidence that my client does not pose a significant risk to themselves or others, and that their mental illness does not meet the threshold for commitment.

Secondly, I would argue that there are less restrictive alternatives to civil commitment that would be more appropriate for my client. This could include outpatient treatment, therapy, or medication management. I would present evidence that my client is willing and able to participate in these alternative forms of treatment, and that they do not require the level of restriction and loss of autonomy that comes with civil commitment.

Finally, I would argue that civil commitment is not in the best interest of my client. I would present evidence that the negative effects of civil commitment, such as stigmatization and loss of rights, would outweigh any potential benefits. I would also argue that my client has a support system in place that can help them manage their mental illness without the need for civil commitment.

Imagine That You Are a Defense Attorney Arguing Against Civil