Under which of the following circumstances might a gallon of water be more valuable than a flawless one carat diamond?
A) At a diamond shop next door to a clean public drinking fountain.
B) At a diamond shop next door to a typical grocery store selling bottled water.
C) In any U.S. city with safe, clean drinking water.
D) In a life raft with 8 passengers who have been adrift on a remote part of the Pacific Ocean for a week with few prospects of an immediate rescue.

Question

Under which of the following circumstances might a gallon of water be more valuable than a flawless one carat diamond? ​
A) ​At a diamond shop next door to a clean public drinking fountain.
B) ​At a diamond shop next door to a typical grocery store selling bottled water.
C) ​In any U.S. city with safe, clean drinking water.
D) ​In a life raft with 8 passengers who have been adrift on a remote part of the Pacific Ocean for a week with few prospects of an immediate rescue.

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

In a life raft with 8 passengers who have been adrift on a remote part of the Pacific Ocean for a week with few prospects of an immediate rescue, a gallon of water would be more valuable than a flawless one carat diamond because water is necessary for survival and can mean the difference between life and death in this situation. The diamond would not have any practical use in this scenario. In all other scenarios presented, access to clean drinking water is readily available, making a gallon of water less valuable than a valuable diamond.

Under Which of the Following Circumstances Might a Gallon of Water