Which of the following statements is/are true about critically appraising the quality of evidence found in the evidence-based practice search process?
A) All evidence produced by randomized clinical trials should be deemed strong evidence
B) Randomized clinical trials always reside at the top of any research hierarchy.
C) Only evidence produced by randomized clinical trials should be considered as worthy of guiding practice decisions, regardless of the nature of the decision.
D) All of the above are true.
E) None of the above is true.

Question

Which of the following statements is/are true about critically appraising the quality of evidence found in the evidence-based practice search process?​
A) ​All evidence produced by randomized clinical trials should be deemed strong evidence
B) ​Randomized clinical trials always reside at the top of any research hierarchy.
C) ​Only evidence produced by randomized clinical trials should be considered as worthy of guiding practice decisions, regardless of the nature of the decision.
D) ​All of the above are true.
E) ​None of the above is true.

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Critically appraising the quality of evidence requires consideration of various factors beyond just the study design, such as sample size, methodological rigor, and potential sources of bias. Therefore, it is not accurate to assume that all evidence produced by randomized clinical trials is strong or that such trials always reside at the top of the research hierarchy. Additionally, evidence from other types of studies, such as observational or qualitative research, could also provide valuable insights and inform practice decisions. Therefore, the statement that only evidence produced by randomized clinical trials should be considered worthy of guiding practice decisions is also incorrect.

Which of the Following Statements Is/are True About Critically Appraising