Mable was employed as a waitress at a respectable restaurant in Winnipeg. After cleaning up at one of the tables, she noticed a valuable broach on the floor beneath the table. Which of the following is correct with respect to her legal claim to the broach?
A) As the finder of the broach, she is entitled to it. She has a prior claim against all but the rightful owner of the broach.
B) She must hand it over to the police, and if the rightful owner does not come forward, the broach becomes the property of the government.
C) Although she found the broach in a public part of the restaurant, she must give the broach to her employer, who has the right to keep it if the rightful owner is not found.
D) Because of the principle of "finders keepers," she gets to keep the broach even against the original owners who lost it.
E) She has no claim to the broach no matter where she found it.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of Mable was employed as a waitress at a respectable restaurant in Winnipeg. After cleaning up at one of the tables, she noticed a valuable broach on the floor beneath the table. Which of the following is correct with respect to her legal claim to the broach?
A) As the finder of the broach, she is entitled to it. She has a prior claim against all but the rightful owner of the broach.
B) She must hand it over to the police, and if the rightful owner does not come forward, the broach becomes the property of the government.
C) Although she found the broach in a public part of the restaurant, she must give the broach to her employer, who has the right to keep it if the rightful owner is not found.
D) Because of the principle of "finders keepers," she gets to keep the broach even against the original owners who lost it.
E) She has no claim to the broach no matter where she found it.

Mable Was Employed as a Waitress at a Respectable Restaurant