The four statements below all involve evaluating a student's essay. Which one is most likely to preserve the student's sense of self-determination?
A) "This essay has the variety of sentence structures that I like to see in my students' writing."
B) "This essay is the best one you've written all semester. Please include it in the portfolio you're creating for this class."
C) "Your essay is so good that I'd like to submit it to the statewide essay contest."
D) "In evaluating your essay, why don't you apply the four criteria you've been using all year to critique your written work?"

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Option D allows the student to take ownership and control of their own learning by prompting them to evaluate their essay using familiar criteria. This approach encourages self-reflection and self-improvement, which aligns with the concept of self-determination. The other options involve external evaluation, which can be helpful but may not necessarily promote the student's sense of autonomy.

The Four Statements Below All Involve Evaluating a Student's Essay