Business Law 4th Edition by David Twomey,Marianne Jennings

Exercise 9

Customers of a chat room are using the chat room, Maphia, for access to each other and to transfer Sega games to each other. They are able to avoid paying the $19 to $60 the games cost for purchase in the stores. The users say they are simply transferring files and that there is no crime. The chat room says it cannot stop customers from interacting. Do you think there are any civil or criminal law violations in their conduct? [Sega Enterprises, Ltd. v Maphia, 857 F Supp 679 (ND Cal)]