Deck 12: Are There Objective Truths About Right and Wrong?

Full screen (f)
exit full mode
Question
A claim is objective, in the sense used by the text, if it is either

A) true or false.
B) true or false and its truth or falsity doesn't depend on who makes the claim.
C) true or false and its truth or falsity doesn't depend on who makes the claim, or the time at which the claim is made.
D) true or false and its truth or falsity doesn't depend on who makes the claim, or the time or place at which the claim is made.
Use Space or
up arrow
down arrow
to flip the card.
Question
Which of the following claims is objective?

A) John Lennon is tall.
B) It is raining here.
C) It is legal for a nineteen-year-old to buy beer.
D) There was a Romulan starship orbiting Neptune.
Question
Divine command theory is often thought to rest on the premise that every law

A) must have a lawmaker.
B) must have citizens to follow it.
C) is part of a constitution.
D) is artificial.
Question
The Divine command theory holds that an action is morally wrong because

A) it is forbidden by the Bible, and an action is morally okay because it has not been forbidden by the Bible.
B) it is forbidden by God, and an action is morally okay because it has not been forbidden by God.
C) God has discovered that it is morally wrong, and an action is morally okay because has discovered that it is not morally wrong.
D) God has discovered and passed on to us that it is morally wrong, and an action is morally okay because has discovered and passed on to us that it is not morally wrong.
Question
Divine command theory's understanding of law has been critiqued by scholars who insist that

A) the moral law is a fundamental feature of reality.
B) not every law has citizens who follow it.
C) all laws are artificial.
D) All of the above
Question
__________ argued, "We must have more to go on in the moral life than our own human faculties. In particular, the possibility of success in the moral life requires something which enables us to get out of skepticism. The Christian God has such a function."

A) Thomas Aquinas
B) John Calvin
C) Linda Zagzebski
D) A. J. Ayer
Question
Divine command theory offers the benefit of

A) responding to the challenge of moral skepticism.
B) easily knowing the right and wrong thing to do.
C) resolving all disagreements about right and wrong.
D) All of the above
Question
Divine command theory suffers from which of the following weaknesses?

A) We are committed to following God's commands, even when they are capricious and malevolent.
B) Right and wrong are only "in principle" knowable.
C) God's dead (Nietzsche has informed us).
D) All of the above
Question
Divine command theorists have responded to arguments regarding God's capricious and malevolent commands by claiming such commands

A) being divine, are spiritualia mysteria.
B) being divine, ought not be questioned.
C) are simply impossible.
D) All of the above
Question
Which of the following claims is inconsistent with divine command theory?

A) God could command us to murder, because His command is law.
B) Right and wrong are no more and no less than what God commands.
C) God would not command us to murder because murder is morally wrong.
D) All of the above
Question
__________ argued, "If [God's] will has any cause, there must be something antecedent to it, and to which it is annexed; this it were impious to imagine. The will of God is the supreme rule of righteousness, so that everything which He wills must be held to be righteous by the mere fact of His willing it. Therefore, when it is asked why the Lord did so, we must answer, because He pleased. But if you proceed farther to ask why He pleased, you ask for something greater and more sublime than the will of God, and nothing such can be found."

A) Thomas Aquinas
B) John Calvin
C) Linda Zagzebski
D) A. J. Ayer
Question
Descriptive cultural relativism claims that

A) when it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what's meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of that person's culture.
B) when someone says that an action is morally wrong, what she means is that she personally disapproves of it.
C) when a person says that an action is morally wrong, she means that she would disapprove of it, given ideal conditions.
D) different cultures around the world have different ethical codes, and what is considered wrong in one culture is not considered wrong in other cultures.
Question
As a theory, descriptive cultural relativism is generally considered

A) uncontroversial.
B) false.
C) unintelligible.
D) question begging.
Question
The two different versions of metaethical cultural relativism are __________ relativism and __________ relativism.

A) agent; speaker
B) agent; person
C) speaker; person
D) categorical; hypothetical
Question
Agent relativism claims that when

A) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what's meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of that person's culture.
B) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what is meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of the speaker's culture.
C) someone says that an action is morally wrong, what she means is that she personally disapproves of it.
D) a person says that an action is morally wrong, she means that she would disapprove of it, given ideal conditions.
Question
Speaker relativism claims when

A) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what's meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of that person's culture.
B) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what is meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of the speaker's culture.
C) someone says that an action is morally wrong, what she means is that she personally disapproves of it.
D) a person says that an action is morally wrong, she means that she would disapprove of it, given ideal conditions.
Question
__________ seems to entail not always having to even consider someone's moral argument.

A) Divine command theory
B) Metaethical cultural relativism
C) Expressivism
D) Qualified attitude theory
Question
Simple subjectivism claims that when

A) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what's meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of that person's culture.
B) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what is meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of the speaker's culture.
C) someone says that an action is morally wrong, what she means is that she personally disapproves of it.
D) a person says that an action is morally wrong, she means that she would disapprove of it, given ideal conditions.
Question
__________ has a difficulty trying to give a credible account of moral disagreement and discussion.

A) Divine command theory
B) Simple subjectivism
C) Metaethical cultural relativism
D) The qualified attitude theory
Question
__________ argued, "If I say to someone 'You acted wrongly in stealing that money,' I am not stating anything more if I had simply said 'You stole that money.' In adding that this action is wrong . . . I am simply evincing my moral disapproval of it. It is as if I said 'You stole that money,' in a particular tone of horror, or written it with the addition of some special exclamation marks. This tone, or the exclamation marks, . . . [serves] merely to show that the expression of it is attended by certain feelings in the speaker."

A) Thomas Aquinas
B) John Calvin
C) Linda Zagzebski
D) A. J. Ayer
Question
According to emotivism, "stealing is wrong" means more or less the same as

A) thou shalt not steal.
B) stealing is wrong to me.
C) stealing is wrong in my culture.
D) "boo to stealing!"
Question
Expressivism attempts to solve simple subjectivism's inability to give a plausible account of moral discussion and disagreement by arguing that when they give arguments for their views, they are

A) attempting to shame each other into doing the right thing.
B) attempting to coerce each other into doing the right thing.
C) attempting to modify each other's emotional responses.
D) merely asserting their own emotional responses.
Question
For expressivism, moral claims are

A) always true.
B) always false.
C) either true or false.
D) neither true nor false.
Question
The qualified attitude theory claims that when

A) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what's meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of that person's culture.
B) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what is meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of the speaker's culture.
C) someone says that an action is morally wrong, what she means is that she personally disapproves of it.
D) a person says that an action is morally wrong, she means that she would disapprove of it, given ideal conditions.
Question
The qualified attitude theory does not include which of the following among its ideal conditions?

A) A person is fully informed about the relevant facts.
B) A person has constructed a well formed, deductive argument.
C) A person is psychologically normal, sober, and not suffering from a psychological disorder that affects moral feelings or reasoning.
D) A person is not biased by self-interest.
Question
For the qualified attitude theory to be of any practical use,

A) one must merely attempt to approximate the ideal.
B) one must satisfy at least one condition.
C) one must merely approximate the ideal.
D) one must satisfy each condition.
Question
Explain the term objective as defined by the textbook, being sure to include its relation to truth and falsity.
Question
Describe the divine command theory and at least one objection to it.
Question
Describe the differences between the following views, noting their various strengths and weaknesses: (i) descriptive cultural relativism, (ii) agent relativism, and (iii) speaker relativism.
Question
Explain simple subjectivism and at least one objection to it. How might a simple subjectivist respond to this objection?
Question
Explain expressivism and at least one objection to it. How might an expressivist respond to this objection?
Unlock Deck
Sign up to unlock the cards in this deck!
Unlock Deck
Unlock Deck
1/31
auto play flashcards
Play
simple tutorial
Full screen (f)
exit full mode
Deck 12: Are There Objective Truths About Right and Wrong?
1
A claim is objective, in the sense used by the text, if it is either

A) true or false.
B) true or false and its truth or falsity doesn't depend on who makes the claim.
C) true or false and its truth or falsity doesn't depend on who makes the claim, or the time at which the claim is made.
D) true or false and its truth or falsity doesn't depend on who makes the claim, or the time or place at which the claim is made.
D
2
Which of the following claims is objective?

A) John Lennon is tall.
B) It is raining here.
C) It is legal for a nineteen-year-old to buy beer.
D) There was a Romulan starship orbiting Neptune.
D
3
Divine command theory is often thought to rest on the premise that every law

A) must have a lawmaker.
B) must have citizens to follow it.
C) is part of a constitution.
D) is artificial.
A
4
The Divine command theory holds that an action is morally wrong because

A) it is forbidden by the Bible, and an action is morally okay because it has not been forbidden by the Bible.
B) it is forbidden by God, and an action is morally okay because it has not been forbidden by God.
C) God has discovered that it is morally wrong, and an action is morally okay because has discovered that it is not morally wrong.
D) God has discovered and passed on to us that it is morally wrong, and an action is morally okay because has discovered and passed on to us that it is not morally wrong.
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
5
Divine command theory's understanding of law has been critiqued by scholars who insist that

A) the moral law is a fundamental feature of reality.
B) not every law has citizens who follow it.
C) all laws are artificial.
D) All of the above
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
6
__________ argued, "We must have more to go on in the moral life than our own human faculties. In particular, the possibility of success in the moral life requires something which enables us to get out of skepticism. The Christian God has such a function."

A) Thomas Aquinas
B) John Calvin
C) Linda Zagzebski
D) A. J. Ayer
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
7
Divine command theory offers the benefit of

A) responding to the challenge of moral skepticism.
B) easily knowing the right and wrong thing to do.
C) resolving all disagreements about right and wrong.
D) All of the above
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
8
Divine command theory suffers from which of the following weaknesses?

A) We are committed to following God's commands, even when they are capricious and malevolent.
B) Right and wrong are only "in principle" knowable.
C) God's dead (Nietzsche has informed us).
D) All of the above
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
9
Divine command theorists have responded to arguments regarding God's capricious and malevolent commands by claiming such commands

A) being divine, are spiritualia mysteria.
B) being divine, ought not be questioned.
C) are simply impossible.
D) All of the above
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
10
Which of the following claims is inconsistent with divine command theory?

A) God could command us to murder, because His command is law.
B) Right and wrong are no more and no less than what God commands.
C) God would not command us to murder because murder is morally wrong.
D) All of the above
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
11
__________ argued, "If [God's] will has any cause, there must be something antecedent to it, and to which it is annexed; this it were impious to imagine. The will of God is the supreme rule of righteousness, so that everything which He wills must be held to be righteous by the mere fact of His willing it. Therefore, when it is asked why the Lord did so, we must answer, because He pleased. But if you proceed farther to ask why He pleased, you ask for something greater and more sublime than the will of God, and nothing such can be found."

A) Thomas Aquinas
B) John Calvin
C) Linda Zagzebski
D) A. J. Ayer
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
12
Descriptive cultural relativism claims that

A) when it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what's meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of that person's culture.
B) when someone says that an action is morally wrong, what she means is that she personally disapproves of it.
C) when a person says that an action is morally wrong, she means that she would disapprove of it, given ideal conditions.
D) different cultures around the world have different ethical codes, and what is considered wrong in one culture is not considered wrong in other cultures.
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
13
As a theory, descriptive cultural relativism is generally considered

A) uncontroversial.
B) false.
C) unintelligible.
D) question begging.
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
14
The two different versions of metaethical cultural relativism are __________ relativism and __________ relativism.

A) agent; speaker
B) agent; person
C) speaker; person
D) categorical; hypothetical
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
15
Agent relativism claims that when

A) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what's meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of that person's culture.
B) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what is meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of the speaker's culture.
C) someone says that an action is morally wrong, what she means is that she personally disapproves of it.
D) a person says that an action is morally wrong, she means that she would disapprove of it, given ideal conditions.
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
16
Speaker relativism claims when

A) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what's meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of that person's culture.
B) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what is meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of the speaker's culture.
C) someone says that an action is morally wrong, what she means is that she personally disapproves of it.
D) a person says that an action is morally wrong, she means that she would disapprove of it, given ideal conditions.
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
17
__________ seems to entail not always having to even consider someone's moral argument.

A) Divine command theory
B) Metaethical cultural relativism
C) Expressivism
D) Qualified attitude theory
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
18
Simple subjectivism claims that when

A) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what's meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of that person's culture.
B) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what is meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of the speaker's culture.
C) someone says that an action is morally wrong, what she means is that she personally disapproves of it.
D) a person says that an action is morally wrong, she means that she would disapprove of it, given ideal conditions.
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
19
__________ has a difficulty trying to give a credible account of moral disagreement and discussion.

A) Divine command theory
B) Simple subjectivism
C) Metaethical cultural relativism
D) The qualified attitude theory
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
20
__________ argued, "If I say to someone 'You acted wrongly in stealing that money,' I am not stating anything more if I had simply said 'You stole that money.' In adding that this action is wrong . . . I am simply evincing my moral disapproval of it. It is as if I said 'You stole that money,' in a particular tone of horror, or written it with the addition of some special exclamation marks. This tone, or the exclamation marks, . . . [serves] merely to show that the expression of it is attended by certain feelings in the speaker."

A) Thomas Aquinas
B) John Calvin
C) Linda Zagzebski
D) A. J. Ayer
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
21
According to emotivism, "stealing is wrong" means more or less the same as

A) thou shalt not steal.
B) stealing is wrong to me.
C) stealing is wrong in my culture.
D) "boo to stealing!"
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
22
Expressivism attempts to solve simple subjectivism's inability to give a plausible account of moral discussion and disagreement by arguing that when they give arguments for their views, they are

A) attempting to shame each other into doing the right thing.
B) attempting to coerce each other into doing the right thing.
C) attempting to modify each other's emotional responses.
D) merely asserting their own emotional responses.
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
23
For expressivism, moral claims are

A) always true.
B) always false.
C) either true or false.
D) neither true nor false.
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
24
The qualified attitude theory claims that when

A) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what's meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of that person's culture.
B) it's said that a person's action is morally wrong, what is meant is that the action is condemned by the ethical code of the speaker's culture.
C) someone says that an action is morally wrong, what she means is that she personally disapproves of it.
D) a person says that an action is morally wrong, she means that she would disapprove of it, given ideal conditions.
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
25
The qualified attitude theory does not include which of the following among its ideal conditions?

A) A person is fully informed about the relevant facts.
B) A person has constructed a well formed, deductive argument.
C) A person is psychologically normal, sober, and not suffering from a psychological disorder that affects moral feelings or reasoning.
D) A person is not biased by self-interest.
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
26
For the qualified attitude theory to be of any practical use,

A) one must merely attempt to approximate the ideal.
B) one must satisfy at least one condition.
C) one must merely approximate the ideal.
D) one must satisfy each condition.
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
27
Explain the term objective as defined by the textbook, being sure to include its relation to truth and falsity.
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
28
Describe the divine command theory and at least one objection to it.
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
29
Describe the differences between the following views, noting their various strengths and weaknesses: (i) descriptive cultural relativism, (ii) agent relativism, and (iii) speaker relativism.
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
30
Explain simple subjectivism and at least one objection to it. How might a simple subjectivist respond to this objection?
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
31
Explain expressivism and at least one objection to it. How might an expressivist respond to this objection?
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.
Unlock Deck
k this deck
locked card icon
Unlock Deck
Unlock for access to all 31 flashcards in this deck.