Janice is a lawyer and is listening to two of her colleagues discuss new legislation on dealing with young offenders.Bill is discussing the issues by logically pointing out the facts of the legislation and implications of these changes,whereas Charlene is emotional and recounts details of a case where a young male killed a single mother of four kids.Which of Janice's colleagues is most likely to influence her view on the legislation?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Janice is a lawyer, so it is more likely for her to be influenced by logical and factual arguments rather than emotional anecdotes. Bill is discussing the legislation logically and giving implications of the changes, which Janice would be more inclined to agree with and find convincing. Charlene's emotional anecdote may be powerful, but it may not necessarily provide Janice with the information she needs to make a decision on the legislation.

Janice Is a Lawyer and Is Listening to Two of Her