Aspirin is a drug that relieves pain, and it is appropriately purchased over the counter. Morphine, like aspirin, is a drug that relieves pain. Therefore, it would be appropriate that morphine be available over the counter.
A) Weak analogy.
B) Appeal to pity.
C) Appeal to ignorance.
D) No fallacy.
E) Appeal to unqualified authority.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

This is a weak analogy fallacy because although both aspirin and morphine relieve pain, they are vastly different in terms of their strength, potential for addiction, and harmful side effects. Aspirin is generally safe for most people to take whereas morphine requires a doctor's prescription and must be closely monitored due to its potency and potential for abuse. Therefore, it is not appropriate to assume that just because aspirin is available over the counter, morphine should be as well.

Aspirin Is a Drug That Relieves Pain, and It Is