Solved

Is This Syllogism Valid

Question 197

Multiple Choice

Is this syllogism valid? Is this syllogism valid? A) No, because there is shading in the premises that does not appear in the conclusion. B) No, because the X in the premises is not in the same place as the X in the conclusion. C) No, because the premises make a narrower claim than the conclusion. D) Yes. E) There is not enough information to determine the answer. Is this syllogism valid? A) No, because there is shading in the premises that does not appear in the conclusion. B) No, because the X in the premises is not in the same place as the X in the conclusion. C) No, because the premises make a narrower claim than the conclusion. D) Yes. E) There is not enough information to determine the answer.

A) No, because there is shading in the premises that does not appear in the conclusion.
B) No, because the X in the premises is not in the same place as the X in the conclusion.
C) No, because the premises make a narrower claim than the conclusion.
D) Yes.
E) There is not enough information to determine the answer.

Correct Answer: