Consider the form of the following argument by analogy. $A$ and $B$ are similar
$A$ has property $P$
$B$ has property $P$
Are the premises dependent or independent?

Question

Consider the form of the following argument by analogy. $A$ and $B$ are similar 
$A$ has property $P$ 
$B$ has property $P$
 Are the premises dependent or independent?

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The premises are dependent because the conclusion that $B$ has property $P$ relies on both the similarity between $A$ and $B$ and the fact that $A$ has property $P$. The argument's strength is based on the combination of these premises.

Consider the Form of the Following Argument by Analogy AAA And BBB

Consider the Form of the Following Argument by Analogy $A$ And $B$