In Order to Form an Argument by Analogy Between a and B

In order to form an argument by analogy between A and B, is it necessary that A and B be alike in every way?

A) No, since that is only sometimes possible, depending on what A and B are.
B) No, since if A and B are two different things, they cannot be alike in every way.
C) No, since it is enough that they share a single property.
D) Yes, since otherwise, they would not have enough in common to form a true analogy.
E) Yes, since otherwise the analogy will lack logical strength.