Judge Joanie Justice, Who Is Newly Appointed to the Bench

Judge Joanie Justice, who is newly appointed to the bench, is presented with a question of law involving a cat named Tiger who scratched a neighbor's antique car. The neighbor, Carl, demands justice in the form of full payment from Tiger's owner, Stacy, and also requests that Tiger be shipped to the local animal shelter. Stacy says that she should not have to pay anything because Tiger had never scratched before, that Tiger should be allowed to stay in the neighborhood, and that Carl (who is a grump and never should have brought the lawsuit) should reimburse her for her legal fees. Judge Justice is perplexed. Judge Justice wants to make a good decision, especially since she is new to the bench. Explain how the judge should go about reaching a decision. Discuss in your answer the impact of cases from other jurisdictions, assuming there is no relevant law in Judge Justice's jurisdiction. Also, assuming there is relevant law in Judge Justice's jurisdiction, discuss the applicable legal standard when case law conflicts with a later passed state statute.