What was Freud's central method of collecting data? What are the five deficiencies of this method according to Schultz and Schultz?

Question

What was Freud's central method of collecting data? What are the five deficiencies of this method according to Schultz and Schultz?​

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer is Sigmund Freud's central method of collecting data was psychoanalysis, which primarily involved techniques such as free association, dream analysis, and the examination of slips of the tongue (parapraxes). Through these techniques, Freud aimed to access the unconscious mind of his patients, uncovering repressed thoughts and feelings that were believed to cause neurotic symptoms.

According to Schultz and Schultz, authors of "A History of Modern Psychology," there are several deficiencies in Freud's method of data collection:

1. **Subjectivity**: Freud's interpretations of his patients' thoughts and dreams were highly subjective. The psychoanalytic method lacked objectivity because it relied heavily on Freud's personal insights and biases, which could not be easily verified or refuted by others.

2. **Lack of Generalizability**: Freud's theories were largely based on a small and non-representative sample of the population, primarily affluent Viennese women. This raises questions about the generalizability of his findings to other populations and cultures.

3. **Non-falsifiability**: Many of Freud's theories are considered non-falsifiable because they are constructed in a way that makes them immune to empirical testing or disproof. For example, if a patient disagreed with Freud's interpretation, he might consider that as resistance, which in turn was seen as further evidence for his theory.

4. **Overemphasis on Sexuality**: Freud's theory placed a heavy emphasis on sexual drives and experiences, which Schultz and Schultz and many other critics argue is an overgeneralization that does not account for the complexity and variety of human behavior and motivations.

5. **Retrospective Analysis**: Freud's method often involved retrospective analysis, meaning he relied on adult patients' recollections of childhood experiences. Such memories can be unreliable and distorted, which undermines the validity of the data collected.

These deficiencies have led to significant criticism of Freud's methods and conclusions. While his work was pioneering and laid the groundwork for modern psychotherapy, many aspects of Freudian theory have been challenged or revised in light of subsequent research and methodological advancements in psychology.

What Was Freud's Central Method of Collecting Data? What Are