Suppose an evil villain holds you and ten other people at gunpoint and tells you that she will kill all ten of your fellow prisoners unless you kill one of them yourself.You have no doubts about the veracity of the villain's threats;You believe fully that she will do as she says she will.Therefore,you have two options.The first option is to kill one of the ten people to save the lives of the other nine.The other option is to do nothing and watch the villain kill all ten people.What is a utilitarian likely to decide? What about a deontologist?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of Suppose an evil villain holds you and ten other people at gunpoint and tells you that she will kill all ten of your fellow prisoners unless you kill one of them yourself.You have no doubts about the veracity of the villain's threats;You believe fully that she will do as she says she will.Therefore,you have two options.The first option is to kill one of the ten people to save the lives of the other nine.The other option is to do nothing and watch the villain kill all ten people.What is a utilitarian likely to decide? What about a deontologist?

Suppose an Evil Villain Holds You and Ten Other People