Two historians debate the merits of a recent historical analysis. One claims it is the definitive account of that period; the other argues that the historical period could be analyzed just as legitimately through several other perspectives. What kind of philosophical discussion are these historians having?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

They are engaging in an epistemological discussion, which concerns the nature, scope, and limits of knowledge. In this case, the debate is about how historical knowledge can be understood or interpreted, indicating an epistemological inquiry.

Two Historians Debate the Merits of a Recent Historical Analysis