Sonja and Paul dated each other for about two years before they became engaged. During that time, Paul gave Sonja numerous pieces of valuable jewelry. When they became engaged, Paul gave Sonja his grandmother's diamond ring. One month later, Paul's parents deeded to Sonja and Paul a house to occupy following their marriage. The couple argued and broke their engagement. Paul and Paul's parents initiated legal proceedings for the return of all gifts to Sonja by any or all of them. Under the law of most states, what is the most likely result?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Under most state laws, gifts given before the engagement are considered absolute gifts and need not be returned. However, gifts given after the engagement are considered conditional gifts, and the recipient must return them if the engagement is broken. In this case, Sonja will likely be required to return all the gifts received after the engagement, including the house and the diamond ring. The gifts given before the engagement need not be returned.

Sonja and Paul Dated Each Other for About Two Years