What is the best level of descriptive representation? Theriault and Edwards suggest that the proportion of members of Congress should equal the proportion of the population. Is that the best level or should it be more to make up for past inequality? Or, is just under the proportion of the population acceptable?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer is The best level of descriptive representation is a matter of ongoing debate and can vary depending on the specific context and goals of representation. Theriault and Edwards suggest that the proportion of members of Congress should equal the proportion of the population, which is known as descriptive representation. This approach aims to ensure that the demographics of the legislative body reflect the demographics of the population it represents.

However, some argue that simply matching the proportion of the population may not be sufficient to address past inequalities and systemic barriers to representation. In this view, it may be necessary to have more than proportional representation in order to make up for historical underrepresentation and to ensure that diverse perspectives and experiences are adequately represented in the legislative process.

On the other hand, others may argue that just under the proportion of the population may be acceptable, as long as there is meaningful and effective representation of diverse voices and interests within the legislative body.

Ultimately, the best level of descriptive representation may depend on a variety of factors, including the specific historical and social context, the goals of representation, and the effectiveness of the legislative body in addressing the needs and concerns of the population it represents. It is important to continue to critically evaluate and discuss the best approaches to achieving equitable and inclusive representation in government.

What Is the Best Level of Descriptive Representation? Theriault and Edwards