The Supreme Court has ruled that free speech rights don't apply to students in public schools (Morse v. Frederick, 2007). How does this ruling apply to university students? How might free speech rules differ for students at private vs. public universities?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer is The Supreme Court ruling in Morse v. Frederick (2007) does not categorically state that free speech rights do not apply to students in public schools. Instead, the ruling is more nuanced. The case involved a student at a public high school who displayed a banner reading "BONG HiTS 4 JESUS" at a school-supervised event. The Supreme Court held that the First Amendment does not prevent educators from suppressing student speech at a school-supervised event when that speech is reasonably viewed as promoting illegal drug use.

The implications of this ruling for university students are not straightforward because the context of higher education is different from that of secondary education. Universities, especially public ones, are often seen as marketplaces of ideas where a higher level of free speech is expected and protected. The legal standards applied to high schools do not necessarily apply in the same way to colleges and universities.

For public universities, which are government entities, the First Amendment protections apply more robustly. Courts have generally held that college students enjoy broader free speech rights than younger students because they are adults and because the mission of higher education is tied to the free exchange of ideas. Restrictions on speech at public universities must meet a higher standard of scrutiny and are often subject to strict tests to ensure they do not infringe on constitutional rights.

Private universities, on the other hand, are not directly bound by the First Amendment because they are not government actors. However, many private institutions commit to free speech principles as a matter of policy and through their own codes of conduct. The extent to which free speech is protected at a private university will depend on the institution's policies and the contractual agreements it has with its students. Some states have laws that extend certain free speech protections to students at private universities, but these vary by state.

In summary, while Morse v. Frederick addressed the scope of student speech rights in a public high school context, its direct applicability to university students is limited. Public university students generally enjoy broader free speech rights under the First Amendment, while private university students' rights are more dependent on institutional policies and state laws.

The Supreme Court Has Ruled That Free Speech Rights Don't