The fallacious leap to a nonnatural explanation for a phenomenon is an example of the fallacy of…
A) Appeal to ignorance
B) Begging the question
C) Straw man
D) Division

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The fallacy of appeal to ignorance occurs when one argues that a lack of evidence against a position is proof of its correctness, or that a lack of evidence for a position is proof of its incorrectness. In this context, jumping to a nonnatural explanation because there is no current natural explanation falls under this category, as it assumes that if we cannot explain something through natural means, then it must be explained through nonnatural or supernatural means. This is a classic example of arguing from ignorance, as it relies on the absence of evidence rather than the presence of evidence.

The Fallacious Leap to a Nonnatural Explanation for a Phenomenon