Tom Tomlinson | Caring for Risky Patients: Duty or Virtue

Tom Tomlinson | Caring for Risky Patients: Duty or Virtue
Tomlinson argues that we need to speak of virtues and ideals, not just duty and obligation, when discussing the treatment of potentially deadly diseases like SARS and AIDs. He presents four arguments for the limits of duty, all which fail to prescribe exactly what those limits are. The language of virtues and ideals offers a different vocabulary for understanding the ethics of caring for risky patients, emphasizing the value of altruism and the use of positive models rather than punishment.
-According to Tomlinson, the ___________ fails because the duty implied by it is not a minimal duty borne equally by all.

A) limits of duty argument
B) social contract argument
C) firefighter analogy
D) consistency argument