In the original trolley paper (chapter 54) , Thomson contrasts the trolley case with the surgeon case. In that paper, she argues that in the trolley case, many believe it is okay to kill one person to save five, but they believe that it is not okay to make the same trade-off in the surgeon case. What would Thomson now say about the trolley case versus the surgeon case?
A) The trolley case is still different from the surgeon case; no change.
B) The trolley case is even more different from the surgeon case than she thought.
C) The trolley case is more similar to the surgeon case than she thought.
D) Not enough evidence to know what Thomson would think.
Correct Answer:
Verified
Q5: In the "Bystander's Three Options" case, option
Q6: In "Bystander's Three Options," Thomson believes that
Q7: If you want to save the five
Q8: The "Bystander's Three Options" case is intended
Q9: Thomson would likely agree most that to
Q11: In this paper, Thomson changes the point
Q12: In the "Bystander's Two Options" case, the
Q13: The two moral principles Thomson introduces are
Q14: Thomson argues in "Bystander's Three Options" that
Q15: Thomson argues that the bystander must choose
Unlock this Answer For Free Now!
View this answer and more for free by performing one of the following actions
Scan the QR code to install the App and get 2 free unlocks
Unlock quizzes for free by uploading documents