Most people that Thomson talks to about the surgeon case feel that
A) the surgeon may kill the healthy patient, if it would save five lives.
B) the surgeon may not kill the healthy patient, even to save five lives.
C) the surgeon must kill the healthy patient, because it would save five lives.
D) all of the surgeon's options are very unfortunate.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The surgeon case, often discussed in the context of ethical dilemmas, typically concludes with most people feeling that it is not morally permissible for the surgeon to kill a healthy patient to save five lives. This reflects a common ethical intuition that it is wrong to actively harm an innocent person, even for the greater good.

Most People That Thomson Talks to About the Surgeon Case