What does it mean to say that a principle has counterintuitive implications?
A) That the principle's logical implications conflict with some moral intuition.
B) That the arguments for the principle rely on implied premises that are not plausible.
C) That the principle must be supported by counting the number of moral intuitions that agree with it.
D) That the principle leads to unexpected and enlightening moral conclusions.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

A principle having counterintuitive implications means that its logical consequences are at odds with our initial moral intuitions or gut feelings about what is right or wrong. This does not necessarily mean the principle is incorrect, but rather that it challenges our preconceived notions.

What Does It Mean to Say That a Principle Has