What is Aristotle's argument in I.5 that the life of politics is not the best life possible for humans?
A) Political honor depends on other people's views of you, whereas happiness is something that people cannot easily take away from you. Therefore, the political life cannot be the happiest life.
B) Politics is about solving problems, whereas true happiness consists in not having any problems. Therefore, the political life cannot be the happiest life.
C) Being successful in politics often requires acting in ways that are not virtuous, but the happiest life is the virtuous life. Therefore, the political life cannot be the happiest life.
D) Even social animals, such as dogs or sheep, have a sort of political life, whereas the happiest life for humans must be something special to humans. Therefore, the political life cannot be the happiest life.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Aristotle argues that political honor is contingent upon the opinions and judgments of others, which can be fickle and unreliable. True happiness, in contrast, is seen as a more stable and self-sufficient state that does not depend on the fluctuating views of others. Thus, he concludes that a life seeking political honor cannot be the best or happiest life for humans.

What Is Aristotle's Argument in I