Which of the following is NOT a premise used by Nathanson to argue against equality retributivism?
A) Individuals' moral deserts are determined purely by the nature of their actions.
B) Equality retributivism requires that barbaric actions be punished barbarically.
C) Equality retributivism offers no plausible guidance on how to punish many crimes.
D) Individuals should be punished based on their being deserving of the punishment.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Nathanson argues against equality retributivism by critiquing its implications and practicality, but he does not claim that individuals' moral deserts are determined purely by the nature of their actions as a premise against it.

Which of the Following Is NOT a Premise Used by Nathanson