Which of the following does NOT, according to Thompson, follow from the fact (if it is one) that you ought to let the violinist use your kidneys?
A) If you refuse, you are self-centered.
B) If you refuse, you are callous.
C) The violinist has a right to use your kidneys and you are being unjust if you refuse.
D) If you refuse, you are not a Good Samaritan.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Thompson argues that even if one ought to let the violinist use their kidneys, it does not necessarily mean the violinist has a right to use them or that refusing would be unjust. Her argument is centered around the distinction between moral decency (e.g., being a Good Samaritan) and moral obligation or rights.

Which of the Following Does NOT, According to Thompson, Follow