Which of the following, according to Shue, constitutes the escape condition necessary to justify instances of interrogational torture?
A) The subject of torture has the ability to physically flee his captors while in custody.
B) The subject of torture has the ability to end the torture by complying with his captors.
C) The subject of torture has attempted in the past to evade or escape from his captors.
D) The subject is first allowed to escape torture by betraying his or her highest values.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Shue argues that for interrogational torture to be justifiable, the person being tortured must have the ability to end the torture by complying with the demands of the captors. This condition is meant to provide the subject with a form of control over the situation, theoretically making the act of torture less morally objectionable since the subject has the power to stop it.

Which of the Following, According to Shue, Constitutes the Escape