Select the fallacy or bad argument technique which occurs in the following argument: The Social Development Minister says too many people want hand-outs from the government. She can talk! She spent years receiving government assistance.
A) False dilemma
B) Ad hominem
C) Tu quoque
D) Mistaking correlation for cause

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

This argument uses the tu quoque fallacy, which is also known as the "you're another" fallacy. This is where instead of addressing the argument being made, the speaker attempts to discredit the person making the argument by pointing out their own hypocrisy or wrongdoing. In this case, the speaker dismisses the Social Development Minister's statement by noting her own history of receiving government assistance. This is a fallacy because it does not address the issue of whether too many people rely on government assistance.

Select the Fallacy or Bad Argument Technique Which Occurs in the Following