Which of the following is NOT a test of argument from cause?
A)Is the cause capable of producing the effect?
B)Is the effect produced by the cause or did it occur coincidentally with the cause?
C)Can the symptom in question be taken as reliable?
D)Has such an effect always followed such a cause?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The other three choices are all relevant tests of argument from cause. Choice A asks whether the cause is capable of producing the effect, which is important in determining whether the causal relationship is plausible. Choice B asks whether the effect is actually caused by the purported cause or whether it occurred coincidentally, which is important in determining whether the causal relationship is truly present. Choice D asks whether the cause-effect relationship is consistent over time, which helps establish whether the relationship is reliable. Choice C, on the other hand, asks whether a symptom can be taken as reliable, which is not a direct test of argument from cause.

Which of the Following Is NOT a Test of Argument