Penelhum argues that
A) the memory criterion has priority over the bodily continuity criterion.
B) the bodily continuity criterion has priority over the memory criterion.
C) the memory criterion and bodily continuity criterion are equally plausible.
D) neither the memory criterion nor the bodily continuity criterion is plausible.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Penelhum argues that the bodily continuity criterion is more plausible than the memory criterion in determining personal identity. He argues that our bodies maintain a continuous physical stream of existence over time, while our memories are subject to change and loss. Therefore, bodily continuity should take priority in determining personal identity.

Penelhum Argues That