Johnson suggests that his argument for the pre-existence of the soul paves the way for the idea of reincarnation, but does not require the idea of reincarnation. Do Johnson's arguments for the pre-existence of the soul work if one supposes that each soul is only incarnated once, but that some pre-existing souls are simply better than others? Why or why not?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of Johnson suggests that his argument for the pre-existence of the soul paves the way for the idea of reincarnation, but does not require the idea of reincarnation. Do Johnson's arguments for the pre-existence of the soul work if one supposes that each soul is only incarnated once, but that some pre-existing souls are simply better than others? Why or why not?

Johnson Suggests That His Argument for the Pre-Existence of the Soul