One possibility raised in the Euthyphro is that actions may be good because God says they are good. What problems does Cahn point out with this view?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer is Cahn points out several problems with the view that actions may be good because God says they are good.

First, he argues that this view implies that morality is arbitrary and based solely on God's commands. This raises the question of whether something is good because God commands it, or if God commands it because it is good. If the former is true, then morality becomes arbitrary and subject to the whims of a divine being. If the latter is true, then there must be some standard of goodness independent of God, which undermines the idea that God is the source of morality.

Second, Cahn raises the issue of divine command theory leading to moral relativism. If morality is solely based on God's commands, then different religions or interpretations of God's will could lead to conflicting moral standards. This undermines the idea of objective moral truths and leads to moral relativism.

Finally, Cahn points out that the divine command theory raises the problem of interpreting God's commands. If morality is based on God's commands, then it becomes crucial to accurately interpret what God commands. This raises the question of how we can know what God commands, and whether our interpretations are reliable.

Overall, Cahn argues that the view that actions may be good because God says they are good raises significant problems regarding the nature of morality, the source of moral standards, and the interpretation of divine commands.

One Possibility Raised in the Euthyphro Is That Actions May