The Donatist controversy began with the problem of the authority of bishops who had renounced the faith under persecution, but were now restored. Augustine's position was that the sacramental power that they administrated had nothing to do with their personal holiness but only God's grace. Is this a coherent position? How is it defensible or not to have sinful ministers who still have sacramental authority?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of The Donatist controversy began with the problem of the authority of bishops who had renounced the faith under persecution, but were now restored. Augustine's position was that the sacramental power that they administrated had nothing to do with their personal holiness but only God's grace. Is this a coherent position? How is it defensible or not to have sinful ministers who still have sacramental authority?

The Donatist Controversy Began with the Problem of the Authority