Suppose you had the opportunity to have someone else make all of your decisions for you for the rest of your life. Suppose further that this person knows you so incredibly well that her decisions are guaranteed to make you happier in the long term than you would be if you made your own decisions. Would you accept such an arrangement? Why or why not? What does this case tell us about the plausibility of hedonism?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer is I would not accept such an arrangement, even if the person making the decisions for me knew me incredibly well and could guarantee my long-term happiness. While it may seem appealing to have someone else take on the burden of decision-making and ensure my happiness, I value my autonomy and the ability to make my own choices, even if they may not always lead to the greatest long-term happiness.

This case tells us that hedonism, the belief that pleasure and happiness are the ultimate good, may not be entirely plausible. While it is important to pursue happiness and pleasure, it is also important to consider other factors such as autonomy, personal growth, and the ability to make choices that align with our values and beliefs. This case highlights the complexity of human happiness and the limitations of relying solely on hedonistic principles to guide our lives. Ultimately, the pursuit of happiness should be balanced with other important values and considerations.

Suppose You Had the Opportunity to Have Someone Else Make