According to the text, why can't the desire satisfaction theorist maintain that what's good for us is the pleasure we feel when certain desires are satisfied?
A) Because this is to say the pleasure rather than the desire satisfaction is what makes us better off
B) Because not all pleasure is good for us
C) Because sometimes we're better off when our desires are satisfied and we don't know it
D) None of the above

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The desire satisfaction theorist claims that what makes us better off is the satisfaction of our desires. However, if they maintain that it is the pleasure we feel when certain desires are satisfied that makes us better off, they are actually prioritizing pleasure over desire satisfaction. This goes against their own theory, which is based on the idea that desire satisfaction is what makes us better off.

According to the Text, Why Can't the Desire Satisfaction Theorist