According to the Argument from Disagreement, if well-informed, rational people persistently disagree about some claim, then
A) we are justified in believing that claim.
B) we are not justified in believing that claim.
C) it is not a moral claim.
D) None of the above

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Argument from Disagreement suggests that if there is persistent disagreement among well-informed and rational people about a claim, then it is not justified to believe that claim until more evidence or a consensus is reached. This is because the existence of disagreement undermines the confidence in the truth of the claim, as there are equally intelligent and informed people who hold opposing beliefs. Therefore, option B ("we are not justified in believing that claim") is the best choice.

According to the Argument from Disagreement, If Well-Informed, Rational People