One might object to the Dependency Argument on the grounds that

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

All three statements are true and provide valid objections to the Dependency Argument. Just because a being is dependent on us does not give us the right to treat them however we wish, as seen in the case of human babies. Dependence alone also does not provide sufficient grounds for justifying current farming and lab practices, as ethical considerations should still be taken into account. Overall, the Dependency Argument simplifies the complex relationship between humans and animals and ignores important ethical considerations.

One Might Object to the Dependency Argument on the Grounds