Some opponents of the Argument from Just Deserts claim that if no one freely chooses to do anything, then

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Argument from Just Deserts is based on the idea that people should receive punishments or rewards that correspond to their actions, which implies a belief in free will. If no one freely chooses to do anything, then the idea of justly punishing someone for their actions becomes problematic. Without free will, no one is truly responsible for their actions, and therefore, no one can be justly punished.

Some Opponents of the Argument from Just Deserts Claim That