Which of the following is inconsistent with Nathanson's proportional retributivism?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Nathanson's proportional retributivism holds that punishment must be proportional to the severity of the crime committed. Punishing an innocent person to prevent a riot would not be proportional to any crime committed, and therefore inconsistent with Nathanson's theory. Executing a murderer, on the other hand, would be proportional to the severity of the crime committed. Abolishing the death penalty does not necessarily contradict proportional retributivism, as long as other forms of punishment are still proportional to the severity of the crime.

Which of the Following Is Inconsistent with Nathanson's Proportional Retributivism