All of the Following Refer to Plessy V

All of the following refer to Plessy v. Ferguson except

A) A mulatto male sought to sit in the white compartment of the East Louisiana Railway.
B) The Supreme Court upheld the principle of "separate but equal" in public accommodations.
C) The plaintiff's lawyer argued that government should not divide people arbitrarily.
D) The lower court found that segregation was in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution even if railroad facilities were substantially equal for both races.