Sherri Ortner claimed that "we find women subordinated to men in every known society." The criteria she used to constitute evidence that a given society considered women inferior are as follows: explicit devaluation, implicit devaluation, and social-structural arrangements barring women from the highest powers within a society. Is it possible that this subordination is as pan-cultural and pan-temporal as she claims? Search the anthropological literature to try to find a society anywhere in the world at any point in time that breaks this pattern. If a female-dominant or co-dominant society cannot be found, ponder Ortner's analysis. On the other hand, speculate on the possibility that the historical record might have been erased. Is it conceivable that the patriarchy might go that far to maintain the status quo of male superiority?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of Sherri Ortner claimed that "we find women subordinated to men in every known society." The criteria she used to constitute evidence that a given society considered women inferior are as follows: explicit devaluation, implicit devaluation, and social-structural arrangements barring women from the highest powers within a society. Is it possible that this subordination is as pan-cultural and pan-temporal as she claims? Search the anthropological literature to try to find a society anywhere in the world at any point in time that breaks this pattern. If a female-dominant or co-dominant society cannot be found, ponder Ortner's analysis. On the other hand, speculate on the possibility that the historical record might have been erased. Is it conceivable that the patriarchy might go that far to maintain the status quo of male superiority?

Sherri Ortner Claimed That "We Find Women Subordinated to Men