What does a philosopher mean when he or she claims not to understand something?
A) He or she believes the account is nonsense.
B) He or she is not satisfied with the account given.
C) He or she is declaring the account too riddled with error to be able to pass judgment on it.
D) He or she is just teasing.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

When a philosopher claims not to understand something, it means that he or she is not satisfied with the account given. It doesn't necessarily mean that the philosopher believes the account is nonsense or that it is too riddled with error to pass judgment on it. They may simply find the explanation unsatisfactory and requires further clarification or a better argument. It is unlikely that the philosopher is just teasing, as philosophy is a serious and rigorous discipline.

What Does a Philosopher Mean When He or She Claims