One argument for thinking that a life without an immortal soul must be meaningless is that:
A) With an immortal soul, our lives are free and proceed randomly.
B) With an immortal soul, our lives are unfree but always do the right thing.
C) Without an immortal soul, we lack the freedom to choose between right and wrong.
D) Without an immortal soul, we freely choose to do wrong more often than right.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The argument posits that the absence of an immortal soul removes the capacity for moral choice, implying that the ability to choose between right and wrong gives life meaning.

One Argument for Thinking That a Life Without an Immortal