When Frank asks. "Let me get this clear; did you mean that I was wrong that this book is red, or that I was wrong that it seems red to me?" The Epistemologist answers that Frank ...
A) is wrong when he says that the book is red.
B) is wrong when he says that it seems red to him.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Epistemologist is trying to clarify whether Frank is claiming that the book is not actually red or if he is claiming that the book appears a different color to him. By stating that he was wrong about it seeming red to him, Frank is admitting that the book appears red to him, but he may be wrong about the actual color of the book. Therefore, the Epistemologist would say that Frank is wrong about it seeming red to him, rather than the book being red.

When Frank Asks