All philosophers respect each other. Some philosopher doesn't study some philosopher. Anything which respects something without studying it is open-minded, if ignorant. So something is open-minded and ignorant. (Ix: x is ignorant; Ox: x is open-minded; Px: x is a philosoper; Rxy: x respects y; Sxy: x studies y)
-Which of the following is the best translation into F of this argument?
A) 1. (∀x) (∀y) [(Px • Py) ⊃ (Rxx • Ryy) ] 2. (∃x) (∃y) [(Px • Py) • ~Sxy]
3) (∀x) (∀y) [(Rxy • ~Sxy) ⊃ (Ox Ix) ] / (∃x) (Ox • Ix)
B) 1. (∀x) (∀y) [(Px • Py) ⊃ (Rxy ≡ Ryx) ] 2. (∃x) (∃y) [(Px • Py) • ~Sxy]
3) (∀x) (∀y) [(Rxy • ~Sxy) ⊃ (Ox Ix) ] / (∃x) (Ox • Ix)
C) 1. (∀x) (∀y) [(Px • Py) ⊃ (Rxy • Ryx) ] 2. (∃x) (∃y) [(Px • Py) • ~Sxy]
3) (∀x) (∀y) [(Rxy • ~Sxy) ⊃ (Ox Ix) ] / (∃x) (Ox • Ix)
D) 1. (∀x) (∀y) [(Px • Py) ⊃ (Rxy • Ryx) ] 2. (∃x) [Px • (∃y) (Py • ∼Sxy) ]
3) (∀x) (∀y) [(Rxy • ∼Sxy) ⊃ (Ox • Ix) ] / (∃x) (Ox • Ix)
E) 1. (∀x) (∀y) [(Px • Py) ⊃ (Rxx • Ryy) ] 2. (∃x) (∃y) [(Px • Py) • ~Sxy]
3) (∀x) (∀y) [(Rxy • ~Sxy) ⊃ (Ox Ix) ] / (∃x) (Ox Ix)
Correct Answer:
Verified
Q59: [(∀x)Pax • ∼(∃x)Pxa] ⊃ (∀x)(Pax • ∼Pxa)
-Consider
Q60: [(∀x)Pax • ∼(∃x)Pxa] ⊃ (∀x)(Pax •
Q61: All cheetahs are faster than some tigers.
Q62: All cheetahs are faster than some tigers.
Q63: All cheetahs are faster than some tigers.
Q65: All philosophers respect each other. Some
Q66: All philosophers respect each other. Some philosopher
Q67: determine whether the given argument is valid
Q68: determine whether the given argument is
Q69: determine whether the given argument is
Unlock this Answer For Free Now!
View this answer and more for free by performing one of the following actions
Scan the QR code to install the App and get 2 free unlocks
Unlock quizzes for free by uploading documents