According to Rachels, if right conduct is right because God commands it, then

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Rachels argues that if right conduct is right simply because God commands it, then God's commands are arbitrary. This is because there is no external standard to which we can compare God's commands to determine whether they are right or wrong. This would mean that if God commanded us to do something immoral, like commit genocide or torture innocent people, it would be considered morally right simply because God commanded it, which seems highly implausible. This is known as the Euthyphro dilemma, and it challenges the idea that morality is dependent on divine authority.

According to Rachels, If Right Conduct Is Right Because God