"Nadine has six children, so she is probably Catholic or Mormon." What is the claim in this argument?
A) Nadine has six children
B) She is probably Catholic or Mormon
C) A large family is not a reliable sign of one's religion
D) In general, Catholics and Mormons tend to have large families

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The claim in this argument is that Nadine is probably Catholic or Mormon based on her having six children. This is stated in option B. Option A is a fact that supports the main claim. Option C is an alternative view that contradicts the main claim. Option D is a generalization that supports the main claim. However, since options A, C, and D are not the main claim, they are not the best choice for the answer.

"Nadine Has Six Children, So She Is Probably Catholic or Mormon