Which of the following best articulates the problem of evil?
A) Theism implies that ours is the best possible universe. But ours is not the best possible universe. Therefore, theism is false.
B) Atheism implies that ours is the worst possible universe. But ours is not the worst possible universe. Therefore, atheism is false.
C) Theism implies that ours is the best possible universe. Ours is the best possible universe. Therefore, theism is true.
D) Atheism implies that ours is the worst possible universe. Ours is the worst possible universe. Therefore, atheism is true.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The problem of evil is the argument that the existence of evil and suffering in the world is incompatible with the concept of an all-powerful, all-knowing, and perfectly good God. Option A articulates this problem by pointing out that if theism is true, we would expect to live in the best possible universe. However, the existence of evil and suffering suggests that this is not the case, which poses a challenge to the coherence of theism. Options B and D are not relevant because they do not address the problem of evil. Option C is problematic because it asserts that ours is the best possible universe, which is not a universally accepted claim, and it also does not address the problem of evil.

Which of the Following Best Articulates the Problem of Evil