Divine command theory suffers from which of the following weaknesses?
A) We are committed to following God's commands, even when they are capricious and malevolent.
B) Right and wrong are only "in principle" knowable.
C) God's dead (Nietzsche has informed us).
D) All of the above

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Divine command theory is based on the idea that morality is determined by God's commands. However, this presents a weakness because it raises the question of whether we are obligated to follow God's commands even if they are unjust or malicious. This can lead to moral dilemmas and conflicts within the theory itself. Option B is not entirely accurate as proponents of divine command theory argue that we can learn about God's commands through religious texts, prophets, or personal revelation. Option C is irrelevant as it does not address the weaknesses of divine command theory.

Divine Command Theory Suffers from Which of the Following Weaknesses